Sweet Pies
Delicious sweet pies baked fresh daily.
Classic Tiramisu
First Crust twist on classic tiramisu made with coffee-soaked ladyfingers covered with a cream of egg yolks, sugar, mascarpone, and cocoa powder. Small Dish serves 2-3 persons. Large dish serves 12 persons
Pumpkin Pie
Luscious Pumpkin custard filling, delicately spiced with traditional American pumpkin spices. 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Easter Basket Lemon Meringue Pie
Easter Basket Lemon Meringue Pie
Peanut Butter Chocolate Crunch Pie
Toasted cookie crust with chopped salted peanuts, layered with peanut butter cream, chocolate fudge and more toasted peanuts!
Santa's Chocolate Peppermint Pie
Chocolate Cookie crust, layered with dark chocolate peppermint pudding topped with snowy white cheesecake peaks and crushed peppermint candy! yum!
Very Berry Pie
An ultimate blend of Blueberries, Raspberries, Strawberries, and Cherries simmered in a sweet confection and baked in our flaky crust and topped with lattice crust. 5 Inch is for 2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons. Menu image is of 8 Inch Pie
Cherry Crumb Pie
Fresh cherries are simmered with our special spice mix and topped with oat cookie crumbles. 5 Inch Serves 1-2 persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
BooCherry Mummy Pie
Freshly made cherry compote, topped with oat cookie crumble baked in buttery flaky crust
Witch Finger Mud Pie
Mississippi Mud pie is a three-layered chocolate-lover's delight, which got a spooky halloween make over! Layers of crumbly cookie crust, goeey chocolate center, and rich sauce on top make this pie irresistible. 5 inch is 1-2 person serving, 8 inch is for 6-8 person serving
Witch Finger Pecan Pie
A nutty delight with decadent gooey filling made of pecans. Rich caramel-like homemade filling with roasted pecans. 5 Inch serves 1-2 person, 8 inch serves 6-8 persons
Spooktacular Pie Box
Halloween Spook Bundle Contains 4 5 inch pies: Jack o Lantern Pumpkin, BooCherry Mummy, Spider Web Banoffee, Witch finger Mud Pie.
Banana Cream Pie
Filled with rich vanilla pudding, fresh banana slices, topped with whipped cream, toasted coconut and caramel sauce makes it supreme. 5 inch is for 1-2 persons, 8 inch for 8-10 persons, 10 inch for 12 persons
Gift Basket
A Beautiful large brown basket tied with white net and Ribbon. The Product details is as follows: 1) Soft Toy 25 cm 2) A Chocolate Bento Cake with a heart 3) 4 Cookies, chocolate Chunk and Red Velvet cookies 4) 6 Chicken Mushroom Hand Pies 5) 4 Brownies LIMITED QUANTITIES AVAILABLE
Pie Shots Bundle
A box of 12 Pie shots including Sticky date pudding, Cherry Cheesecake, Banoffee Pie and Lotus Cheesecake. Perfect bite sized desserts for your gatherings or a hostess gift.
Happy Birthday Card
Happy Birthday Greeting Card L:12.7 CM , H: 8.8 cm
Happy Birthday Card - Favorite Person
Happy Birthday Love Card with Envelope – Blank Inside, Premium Paper
Get Well Soon Card
Humorous 'You're One Tough Cookie' Greeting Card Size: 14.73*10.41cm
Confession Teddy Bear
Major Material: PP Color: Light Brown
Signature Unbaked Single Crust
Now you can bake the pie at home with a little assistance from the pie experts! We’ve hand-rolled and crimped our signature butter pie dough and placed it in a disposable pie pan of 9 Inch diameter, ready to bake. All you have to do is follow your favorite recipe, fill it, and bake! Can be used for any pie or quiche recipe that uses a single bottom crust. Store in the freezer for up to 6 months, or in the refrigerator for up to 2 days before baking. You can purchase up to 4 single crusts at a time.
Signature Pie Dough
Now you can purchase our signature handmade pie dough for your home baking! Get the perfect pie crust every time with this versatile dough. The dough can be used for sweet or savory pies, or as a base crust for quiche. 1 dough round = 1 single bottom crust // 2 dough rounds = 1 bottom crust & 1 top crust. Store in the freezer for up to 6 months, and in the refrigerator for 2 days. To thaw frozen dough: take out the dough needed and thaw it in the refrigerator overnight, or allow about 2 hours to thaw on the countertop before it’s ready to roll out. You can purchase up to 4 dough rounds at a time.
Spider Web Banoffee Pie
Buttery pie crust, filled with banana slices and delicious toffee filling, topped with whipped cream and chocolate fudge! 5 Inch serves 1-2 person, 8 inch serves 6-8 persons
First Crust Bakery Gift Card
First Crust Bakery Gift Card
Classic Apple Pie
Double-crust pastry filled with fresh tart and sweet Apples tossed in our special homemade spice mix! Highly recommended to serve warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Sticky Date Pudding Bundt
This sticky date pudding pie is sticky and smothered in toffee sauce! it is topped with candied pecans and best served warm with Vanilla ice cream or whipped cream with extra caramel sauce!
Spinach Mushroom Feta Quiche
Sauteed spinach and mushrooms in rich savory egg, cheese and cream filling in our signature flaky butter crust. 4 Inch is for 1 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Shepherd's Pie
Beef mince is cooked down with root vegetables and seasoned with Worcestershire sauce and fresh herbs until dark and rich, we top it with fluffy mashed potato with a little sprinkle of Cheddar cheese. An ultimate comfort food full of flavor! 4 Inch is for 1 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Chocolate Pecan Pie
A nutty chocolate delight with a decadent gooey filling made of pecans and chocolate chips. Rich caramel-like homemade filling with roasted pecans and chocolate chips. Highly recommended with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and strong cup of coffee. 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Mississippi Mud Pie
Mississippi Mud pie is a three-layered chocolate-lover's delight. Layers of crumbly cookie crust, goeey chocolate center, and rich sauce on top make this pie irresistible. 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Key Lime Pie
Delightfully sweet with the perfect amount of tartness, this fresh homemade key lime pie is a winner! 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons, Menu image is of 8 Inch Pie
Banoffee Pie
Cookie crust, filled with banana slices and delicious toffee filling, topped with whipped cream, chocolate fudge and roasted almonds. 5 Inch is for 1- 2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Apple Crumble Pie
Our signature and most popular apple crumble pie is baked with thinly sliced granny smith apples, fresh cream and topped with oat cookie crumble! A must-try! 5 Inch Serves 1-2 Person, 8 Inch Serves 8-10 Persons. 10 Inch Serves 12-14 Persons. Menu image is of 8 Inch Pie
Pecan Pie
A nutty delight with decadent gooey filling made of pecans. Rich caramel-like homemade filling with roasted pecans. Highly recommended with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and strong cup of coffee. 5 Inch is for 1-2 Persons, 8 Inch for 6-8 Persons, 10 inch for 10-12 persons. Menu Image is for 8 Inch Pie
Lemon Meringue pie
This lemon meringue pie is so delicious and perfect for sharing! The sweet and tart lemon filling, topped with light meringue toasted to perfection. 5 Inch Serves 2 Person, 8 Inch Serves 8-10 Persons. Menu image is of 8 Inch Pie
Lotus Blondie Box
Thick, chewy and extremely delicious, these lotus blondies will make you come for more. Box of 2 and Box of 8 blondies are available